Bleed Out, a note
I was disappointed by this piece by Nicholas Orvis in the first issue of Playtest Material. Why?
Some of it has to do with the rushed comparisons being made to establish the identity of practices through which theater and role playing can communicate. Looking to the advice that shows up around PbtA to drive your character like a stolen car, for example, as a mirror of the critical distance that animates things like epic theater and the theater of the oppressed strikes me as wildly rushed. It races past what differentiates the theater of the oppressed from epic theater, for one, and then crams that elision forward into role playing.
I don't think it is any accident that Pasión de las Pasiones, a delightfully innovative use of the PbtA framework, developed in response to the high-drama Latin American telenovela format. But, you know, Boal himself had nothing but bile for the sorts of stories found in the telenovela format, and presumably would not have found much pleasure in a game intended to repeat its structure at a table. The drama of the telenovela (and the drama of the PbtA game) still makes drama and excitement what happens in a life other than that of the spectator–role player.
The way the article circles and raises up bleed specifically as a lesson role playing brings to theatrical discussions frustrates me so much, too.
Both Brecht and Boal were troubled by the immersive dimensions of theater. Both saw it as a moral and political danger, a tool deployed to lock people into toxic forms of state propaganda. The language for talking about that was ancient, Aristotle's cathartic identification. The techniques they deploy to alter and deform classic theater depend upon the frustration of immersive effects, and together form the beginnings of a historical stereoscope through which we can use contemporary criticisms of both the immersive effects of dramatic catharsis and lyric epiphany to view bleed.
To create that stereoscopic depth, though, we need to attend to Boal's trenchant criticism of Brecht in his Theatre of the Oppressed. Boal argues that Brecht's dialectical epic theater is in need of further dialectic because epic theater preserves the spectator relationship as a site of critical reflection, as a kind of space for (personal) epiphany. The critical spectatorship that Orvis describes as unifying Brecht, Boal, and Kemper's reflexive LARP methodology is precisely what Boal wants to dissolve. While Brecht's work remains relevant for Boal, it must be transformed. There is little private in the realization of Boal's participant—they move to the stage, displace the actors, and re-enact alternatives for each other.
The theater of the oppressed is profoundly somatic and aims to provide its participants with the somatic awareness and plasticity necessary to rupture the points to which their bodies have been conditioned by oppressive circumstance. And to develop and explore that by rupturing expected behavior in the theatrical space. An Austen LARP can't take up Boal's call, unless it educates its players in the bodily repression that animates the social forms they are participating in and gives them the practices to disrupt the structure of the scenes themselves. That violates the social contract that animates most LARPs and gives them their internal consistency.
The criticism of both catharsis and epiphany has been an anchor of late for me. I bring some hermeneutic distrust to accounts of role playing that suggest they provide insight into how other people live and experience, that they produce comparably wholesome forms of empathy and release (catharsis), or that the insights that people have within a role playing game are especially morally or ethically efficacious (epiphany).
I want forms that discourage immersion and immediacy, forms that explore the open indefinite of catachresis, index, and inventory, of care and attention that preserve the alterity necessary for any sort of intimacy. Contrast, for example, the well-worn "Yes/And" that role playing lifted from improv theater with the "Not/But" of Brecht's epic/dialectical theater, and then push the Not/But forward into role playing, dissolving the immediacy of a dramatic scene into a situation that can be felt through in its complexity.
Players armed with the Not/But start to look exactly like the sort of dialectical next step that Boal wanted to bring to Brecht's epic theater, one that tilts it properly toward liberation.